YOURSAY | Minister’s snub of PSC makes mockery of Parliament

YOURSAY | ‘Govt servants cannot be above Parliament.’

Education minister refuses to meet PSC, cites cabinet's order - Maszlee

Dr Raman Letchumanan: "They (Education Minister Mohd Radzi Md Jidin and his ministry) gave an excuse that the cabinet did not allow them to attend (a parliamentary select committee meeting)," PSC on education chairperson Maszlee Malik told Malaysiakini after they did not appear at the meeting on Wednesday (April 20).

In July 2021, I wrote this opinion piece where I stated that constitutionally the cabinet is answerable to the Parliament.

In particular, Article 43 (3) of the Federal Constitution states: “The cabinet shall be collectively responsible to Parliament”.

The parliamentary select committees (PSCs) are unanimously agreed by all MPs, both the government and opposition, to inquire into any matter of public interest and report to the Dewan Rakyat for further action.

In this case, it was alleged that the same set of questions in a public exam (SPM) was administered to a subsequent batch of students.

This strikes at the core principle of education - that no one should be allowed to copy or have an undue advantage and pass an exam.

The government (cabinet) should rightfully be alarmed by this expose and take every opportunity to allay the fears of possible manipulation of our education system.

However, the cabinet despite its constitutional obligation refuses to attend an inquiry by Parliament.

The cabinet obviously has violated the Constitution. What is the punishment for that? For them to step down, at least? What is the prime minister's stand on this matter?

Indeed, this goes against the basic principle of parliamentary democracy. The executive (cabinet) having given the full powers to govern the country, now refuses to answer to Parliament for their (mis)deeds, in other words, the rakyat.

Earlier the MACC chief refused to attend an enquiry by Parliament citing deficiencies in the invitation over a scandal involving his shares ownership.

Are the cabinet and government officials making a mockery of Parliament, the highest august institution of the country?

I think the cabinet itself needs an education on our Federal Constitution.

If this matter is not addressed properly and openly, the public cannot be blamed for looking down upon our education system, much maligned as it is.

The Middle Man: Does that mean the PSC is toothless and powerless? The PSC must have the legal authority to summon any parliamentarian or cabinet member to sit in the hearing.

Refusal to attend must warrant punishment like denial of privileges, suspension and if needed, even disqualification of being an MP.

In addition, the PSC should also be empowered to take legal action to enforce its findings otherwise it makes a mockery of the PSC and its functions.

OrangePanther 1466: Refusal to attend Parliament is equivalent to contempt. They should be hauled up and penalised.

Government servants cannot be above Parliament. By refusing attendance, they are belittling the stature of the august House.

OCT: When the government knows that it will be shamed, they show the joker card. The PSC is now seen as a toothless tiger.

It’s as if these government officers like the MACC boss and education minister know that no recourse and/or penalty will be taken against them as they are fully backed by the government.

Are they not answerable to any investigating committee? They seem to be above the law. Culprits and offenders cannot be protected all the way by the government.

Sealthedeal: What has happened to democracy and accountability?

Aisyalam: If Parliament is unable to oversee the government through its select committees (this is not the first time as the head of MACC also didn’t bother to appear), then this is equivalent to a dictatorship where the government can do what it likes and Parliament is used only as a tool to achieve what the government likes.

There might as well be no need to have any type of election. After all, it’s only to show others we are a democratic country when in effect it's otherwise.

MerdekaMerdekaMerdeka: They are known as the PSC. So, when they make a call for anyone to attend any session they chair for whatever matter, their call is made by the Parliament to the ministry.

The Education Ministry chose to ignore it simply because “the cabinet did not allow them to attend"? What a bunch of useless government officials and what a garbage reason.

One: Talk about lazy government servants. They were too lazy to even prepare a second set of questions for SPM exams apparently.

And now they are too cowardly to come and face the music. Again, these are confirmed signs of a failed government and a laughing stock for the whole world. Vote them out!

Iphonezours: Why are these people so scared of facing questions? If you have made a big blunder, own up and resign. What is so difficult about that?

Don’t you people have any sense of responsibility and honour?

The above is a selection of comments posted by Malaysiakini subscribers. Only paying subscribers can post comments. In the past year, Malaysiakinians have posted over 100,000 comments. Join the Malaysiakini community and help set the news agenda. Subscribe now.

These comments are compiled to reflect the views of Malaysiakini subscribers on matters of public interest. Malaysiakini does not intend to represent these views as fact.